With the signing of Daisuke Matsuzaka by the red sox last night, I’ve decided to put together the first (and probably not last) look at the matchups between the New York Yankees and the boston red sox.
Starting pitching:
NY: Pettitte, Mussina, Wang, Johnson, Pavano
bos: Schilling, Beckett, Matsuzaka, Papelbon, Wakefield
I take Pettitte in a big game over anyone on the boston staff any day of the week and twice on Sundays, he’s a lock for at least 15 wins. Mussina and Wang are solid. Wang may very well be the ace of this staff after a 19 win season last year. The back end of the Yankees rotation is a HUGE question mark with Randy “I’m 135 years old” Johnson and Carl “American Idle” Pavano (credit must be given to the NY Daily News reporter who constantly refers to Pavano by that name, and I love it!!).
Schilling is not the Schilling of old, no matter how people in boston try to spin it. He’s not a #1 anymore, but he’ll probably pitch on opening day so I’ve listed him atop the sox rotation. Beckett is yet to be seen if he can adapt to the American League. Had a decent season last year, but not as good as what was expected of him in boston. Matsuzaka, from all indications, has what it takes to be a superstar, time will tell, he could turn out to be the best of the bunch. Papelbon as a starter? Who knows how he’ll hold up, could be great. Wakefield, aka rubber arm, is a more than serviceable #5 starter, you can pencil him in for 12 wins and 12 losses every year.
Advantage: right now, I gotta give it to the Yanks…too many question marks on the boston side.
Lineup:
NY: Posada, (1b unclear), Cano, Jeter, Rodriguez, Abreu, Damon, Matsui, and Giambi at DH
bos: Varitek, Youkilis, Pedroia, Lugo, Lowell, Drew, Crisp, Ramirez and Ortiz at DH.
Behind the plate it’s a wash…1b we’ll have to wait and see who the Yanks end up playing there, so right now we gotta give it to the sox. 2b, ss, and 3b are not even close, Yanks, Yanks, and Yanks. Same goes for rf and cf. In left, Manny gets the advantage offensively while Matsui is a better defensive outfielder. And finally at dh, Ortiz over Giambi.
Advantage: offensively the Yanks have a better lineup (regardless of who plays 1b)…defensively the edge is to the Yanks as well, with very little if any arguments from even the biggest red sox fan.
Bullpen: I’m going to reserve comparing these until a later time…currently the red sox don’t have a closer, so until the bullpen picture becomes clearer, I’ll withhold judgement.
Coaching: I won’t even dignify that with any kind of comment…if you can’t distinguish between one of the best managers in the game and Terry Francona, you know less than I thought you did.
Well, that’s the first of what I’m sure are more baseball postings to come. Many things may/will happen between now and spring training…where will Roger go? Is Manny gonna be Manny in boston or somewhere else. Will A-Rod still be in NY??? Only time will tell…after all pitchers and catchers don’t report for another 60 days or so.
Til next time…